Thinning Fruit

The reasons for thinning fruit are as follows:

  1. Increases annual yields of high quality fruit.
  2. Improves uniformity of fruit size at harvest.
  3. Improves color.
  4. Improves eating quality.
  5. Reduces limb breakage.
  6. Promotes tree vigor and maintains a balance between vegetative growth and fruiting.
  7. Minimizes the handling and storage of low grade or cull fruit.
  8. Permits more thorough spraying of fruits during late season applications.
  9. Expedites all handling operations at harvest and reduces their respective costs.
  10. Prevents trees from biennial production.

A fruit tree commonly produces many more blossoms than should be permitted to set as fruit. Dwarf trees, especially, have a strong tendency to produce more fruit than necessary or even proper for the tree. Ten percent of the flowers on apples and pears are sufficient to produce a full crop; with cherries, peaches, and plums may be allowed to set 20 to 30 percent of their blossoms. Although the natural competition between fruits may reduce the crop somewhat, this reduction in fruit set will not be enough. Fortunately, there are practices that will control the number of fruits on a tree more accurately. The earlier in the season these are performed, the better the result.

Trees should not be allowed to fruit too heavily at too early an age. This will depend upon the rootstock and the variety. If a dwarf type tree is permitted to over produce, the leader of a central leader type tree may be bent severely, and a low, scraggly tree will develop. In the case of dwarf apple trees, it is considered wise to remove all blossoms the first year.

The effect of blossoming and fruiting early in the life of the tree was demonstrated in studies from England by Preston, in which trees were deblossomed for the first seven years after planting and compared with trees not deblossomed. The first crop from the trees that had been deblossomed for seven years was almost equal to the accumulated crops of the trees that were not deblossomed. On the other hand, the deblossomed trees did become biennial following that first heavy crop as all blossoms were allowed to set fruit.

When apple and pear trees bloom and set a heavy crop of fruit, they may become biennial bearers; that is, they bloom and fruit good one year and then bloom and fruit poorly the next year. This habit continues year after year, producing a crop every other year. Dwarfed apple and pear trees can easily become biennial. Therefore, it becomes important to prevent too heavy a set of apples and pears. Blossom thinning or thinning of the young fruits very shortly after bloom is the best way to avoid alternate bearing. Thinning done in midsummer is too late to affect next year's crop materially, since the time is then past when next year's blossom buds are initiated.

The first opportunity to thin is during the dormant period. Pruning is one type of thinning commonly used on peach and nectarine. These trees fruit on one-year old wood, thus excess buds can be reduced by cutting back some of the shoots. See the fact sheet on pruning stone fruit at http://www.coopext.colostate.edu/TRA/PLANTS/pruningstonefruittrees.html. It is best to delay this type of thinning until all danger of winter injury to buds has passed, and after examination of the buds has been made to determine how many are alive. Pruning to thin only removes a certain percentage of blooms and does not control the distribution of the fruit.

The next opportunity to thin is at blossom time. If the bloom is potentially heavy some of it can be literally knocked off with a rubber-tipped pole or a clean toilet bowl brush. This has proved an efficient and practical method for peaches, plums, apricots, and cherries. It can also be used for apples and pears, but is less satisfactory because of the spur-bearing habit of these fruits. The blossoms that remain will set a high percentage of fruit.

Chemical Thinning

Chemical thinning of blossoms and fruit is very effective for apples and pears, but less certain with the stone fruits. The effectiveness of chemical thinning agents is controlled by various environmental conditions that must be taken into consideration. Adjustments must be made to meet these conditions. Varieties also differ in their response to thinning chemicals. The following information, extracted for COLORADO TREE FRUIT PEST AND CROP MANAGEMENT GUIDE - XCM-41, provides guidance on the sprays to use. The recommended chemicals may not be available at your local nursery or garden center, but should be carried by chemical distributors that cater to the fruit industry. It is suggested that these thinning materials be used only on a trial basis for the first year. When a reduced fruit set is expected due to frost, etc., caution should be taken so that excessive thinning and yield reduction will not occur.

Chemical Thinning Guide

Fruit
Variety
Materials Concentration Rate per 100
Gals (Dilute)
1
Remarks

Apples
Bloom Spray
Non-spur
Delicious
1. Elgetol 0.67-1 pt. Apply when three blossoms
per spur cluster are open
on north side of tree.
Golden Delicious,
Jonathan, Winesap,
Spur-type Delicious
1. Elgetol 1-1.33 pt. Apply when three blossoms
per spur cluster are open
on north side of tree.

Post-Bloom Spray - - Avoid killing bees on cover crops in bloom - -
Delicious 1. NAA 200 (+surfactant)**
or NAA 256(+surfactant)**
or Fruitone-N (NAA 3.1 WP)
(+surfactant)
2. Sevin (carbaryl) 50 WP*
2-5 ppm
2-5 ppm
2 ppm

150-300 ppm
.5-1 fl.oz.
.4-.8 fl.oz.
.8 oz.

4-8 oz.
Apply NAA 15-25 days after
full bloom. Sevin once,
any time from 10 to 25 days
after full bloom. Apply
combinations of Sevin and
NAA for increased thinning
on spur-type Red Delicious.
Jonathan,
Rome
1. Sevin 50 WP*
2. NAA 200 (+surfactant)**
or NAA 256 (+surfactant)**
or Fruitone-N (NAA 3.1 WP)
(+surfactant)**
300-600 ppm
3-5 ppm
2.5-5 ppm
3 ppm
8-16oz.
.7-1 fl.oz.
.4-.8oz.
1.2 oz.
Apply NAA 15-25 days after
full bloom, Sevin once any
time for 10 to 25 days
after full bloom. NAA is
less effective on Jonathan
and Rome.
Golden Delicious 1. Amide-Thin W (NAD 8.4%)
(+surfactant)**
2. Amide-Thin W (NAD 8.4%)
(+surfactant)**
+Ethephon
3. NAA 200 (+surfactant)**
or
NAA 256 (+surfactant)**
or
Fruitone W (NAA 3.1 WP)
(+surfactant)**
4. Sevin 50 WP*
or XLR Plus
+
NAA 200
or
Amide-Thin W (NAD 8.4%)
5. Sevin 50 WP*
or Sevin XLR Plus
17-34 ppm

17-34 ppm

300-450 ppm
3-5 ppm

2-5 ppm

3-5 ppm

150-300 ppm
150-300 ppm

3-5 ppm

17 ppm
300-450 ppm
300-450 ppm
3-5 oz.

3.5 oz.

1-1.5 pt.
.7-1 oz.

.4-.8 fl.oz.

1.2-2 oz.

4-8 oz.
4-8 fl.oz.

.7oz.

3 oz.
8-12 oz.
8-12 fl.oz
Apply Amide-Thin W at 7-14
days, Sevin once at 10-25
days, NAA at 15-25 days
after full bloom Delay
NAD + ethephon combination
spray to 10-20 days after
full bloom. For greater
thinning, use lower rates
of NAA or NAD with Sevin.
NAD plus ethephon gives
greater thinning and return
bloom
Winesap 1. Amide-Thin W (NAD 8.4%)
(+surfactant)**
2. *Sevin 50 WP
3. NAA 200 (+surfactant)**
or NAA 256 (+surfactant)**
or NAA 3.1 WP
(+surfactant)**
17 ppm

450 ppm
2-5 ppm
2-5 ppm
2-5 ppm
12 oz.
.5-1 oz.
.4-.8 fl.oz.
.8-2.0 oz.
Apply Amide-Thin W at 7-14
days after full bloom
Sevin once any time 10-25
days after full bloom, or
NAA 15-25 days after full
bloom

Pears
Bartlett 1. Amide-Thin W (NAD 8.4%)
(+surfactant)**
10-15 ppm 1.6-2.4 oz. Apply 15-21 days after full
bloom. Amide-Thin W may
over-thin varieties other
than Bartlett.

1Spray to Run-Off. Based on 400 gallons per acre (for average size trees).
*Sevin is highly toxic to bees and predator mites.
**Use surfactant according to manufacturer's recommendations, but not more than 1 pint per 100 gallons of spray.
Note: For easier and more accurate measurement of small amount of liquids, dilute them first. For example,
make a 10 to 1 dilution by putting 1 part in 9 parts water. From this stock solution, measure out and use 10
times the amount shown in the table

Address comments to Dr. Curtis E. Swift, Area Extension Agent, Horticulture
Colorado State Extension
2775 US Hwy 50, Grand Junction, CO. 81503
Phone: 970-244-1834, Fax: 970-244-1700


Placed on the Internet February 17, 2003